Like many of
the metal-on-metal hip implant systems, the DePuy ASR and the DePuy Pinnacle
have had their share of problems. The Pinnacle gained FDA approval in 2000, and
has not been recalled despite adverse reports of failure and metal toxicity.
The ASR was approved in 2005 and spent only five years on the market prior to
being recalled in August of 2010.
November 27, 2012
September 2, 2012
Miss the Filing Deadline for Your DePuy ASR Hip Case? There May Still Be Hope
Despite
the fact that the August, 2010 recall of the DePuy ASR metal-on-metal hip
implant caused a significant stir among the medical community, thousands of
recipients of the metal implant remained unaware of recall and subsequent
warnings. Due to the initial FDA notice which was issued July 17, 2010 and the
recall of the implant on August 24, 2010, all those who live in a state which
operates under a two-year statute of limitations may have already lost their
right to file suit against DePuy and Johnson and Johnson. Over half of the
states do operate under that two year
SOL, while others extend that time limit to three, four, six or even ten years.
A handful of states have a one-year statute of limitations. If you are the recipient of a DePuy metal hip
implant it’s important that you determine your state’s statute of limitations
for defective medical products even if you are currently having no problems
with your implant.
Although
DePuy originally set their metal implant’s failure rate at approximately 5%,
they increased that number to 12% at the time of the 2010 recall. Independent
studies place the likelihood of a DePuy ASR implant failure much higher—50% at
five years following implant surgery and 80% at eight years following implant
surgery. Statistically speaking, even those patients who have not yet
experienced failure of their hip implant or adverse health effects from metal
toxicity will do so in the very near future. It is extremely important that all
DePuy ASR implant recipients at least be aware of their options prior to the
date the statute of limitations will run.
September 1, 2012
The DePuy ASR Metal-on-Metal Hip Implant: A Scientific Analysis of its Problems
The
last ten years have seen surgical replacement of hip joints with an artificial
prosthesis increase significantly. The main reason for this surge in hip
replacement surgeries is our aging population. With people living longer, more
active lives, degenerating hip joints can put a halt to that activity. From
1997 through 2004, the number of hip replacement surgeries increased nearly 50%
and if the trend continues it is estimated that the annual number of hip
replacements in the United States will reach 600,000 by 2015.
Factors in Hip Replacement Surgery
Primary
reasons for patients undergoing hip replacement surgery include chronic pain,
impairment of daily functions and severe arthritis in the hip joint. The most
common type of arthritis leading to total hip replacement is osteoarthritis and
is generally seen with aging or trauma to the hip joint. In some instances
necrosis of the hip can be present, usually caused by a fracture, alcoholism,
lupus, or taking steroid drugs such as prednisone. Patients may experience
progressively worsening chronic pain which prohibits them from walking,
climbing stairs or even getting up from a sitting position.
Types of Hip Implants
There
are many different types of hip replacement implant including the metal-on
metal, metal-on-polyethylene and metal-on-ceramic as well as the implants which
are 100% ceramic or polyethylene. Other than the materials the implant is
constructed with, the only other major difference is in how the implant is
affixed—it can be cemented to the bone or attached in such a manner that it
grows into the patient’s remaining bone. The idea behind the cobalt and
chromium metal-on-metal hip implant was to create an implant which would not
have to be re-done for fifteen to twenty years—unlike the ceramic and
polyethylene hip implants which last approximately 8-12 years.
August 31, 2012
First Three DePuy Cases settled by Johnson & Johnson for over $600,000
The
DePuy metal-on-metal hip implant, approved by the FDA a mere seven years
ago—has been inundated with over 8,000 lawsuits claiming the implant is
inherently defective and can lead to costly and painful revision surgery as
well as a myriad of other serious health issues. DePuy initially claimed the
failure rate of the ASR metal hip implant to be between 4-5%. When DePuy
voluntarily recalled the implant in 2010, they upgraded the failure rate to
approximately 12% within the first five years. Studies independent of DePuy or
Johnson & Johnson place the failure rate of the ASR metal implant at 50%
within six years and 80% within eight years. These staggering numbers almost
guarantee that this particular metal-on-metal hip implant will fail at some
point in the majority of recipients.
Nearly
a hundred thousand ASR devices were implanted worldwide prior to the recall
with nearly forty thousand in the United States alone. The propensity of the
implant to loosen and detach as well as the thousands of reports regarding
adverse health effects from high levels of chromium and cobalt have led to over
6,000 lawsuits filed in federal court an another 2,000 filed at the state level
in Maryland, California, Nevada and other states. Johnson & Johnson
recently settled three Nevada cases for $600,000—an amount considered to be at
the low end of the expected $200,000-$500,000 to settle each case.
These
three lawsuits were expected to go to trial in late 2012 and came from three
women, all over the age of sixty, whose surgeries were performed by the same
surgeon. Each woman had no choice but to undergo revision surgery—a procedure
which is not only extremely painful, but can require months of recuperation and
time away from work. One of the women reported excessive amounts of damage to
the surrounding hip bone as a direct result of the implant yet Johnson &
Johnson countered that the implants were not responsible for any of the
developing life-threatening illnesses. The research regarding the potential of
chromium and cobalt in the bloodstream to cause serious and life-threatening
illnesses is sadly lacking at this point in time.
July 31, 2012
“ASR” type Chromium and Cobalt Poisoning also being seen in Pinnacle Hip Implant Recipients
The DePuy ASRmetal-on-metal hip implant has repeatedly made the news following a voluntary
recall on August 26, 2010. While DePuy’s Pinnacle metal hip implant has not
suffered under the recall stigma, many feel that it offers the same risks to
implant recipients as the ASR. And, in fact, many attorneys are constantly
asked by their clients about the differences between the ASR and the Pinnacle.
The primary distinction between the two metal hip devices lies in the fact that
the Pinnacle uses an insert liner between the acetabular cup and the femoral
head while the ASR does not. It has been theorized that the ASR cup was too
shallow for the head, leading to the ball hitting the edge of the cup and metal
shavings to shear off into the body, also know as edge-loading.
While the Pinnacle’s cup
was designed to give greater depth and allow the femoral head to move more
freely within the socket, in some cases it still has been know to cause
metallosis in implant recipients when the cobalt and chromium ions migrate
around the body. Metal poisoning can cause a wide variety of adverse medical
events. Many ASR recipients have had cardiovascular, renal, neurological and
thyroid issues although studies done in the 70’s do not definitively tie these
metals to cancer. Unfortunately, due to the lack of comprehensive studies on
safe levels of cobalt and chromium in the body and the effects of toxic levels,
nobody really knows just how dangerous these metals can be should they migrate
to the bloodstream. The metal shards can also lodge into the surrounding
tissues causing degeneration and destruction.
July 29, 2012
Attorneys of Sullo & Sullo Seeing DePuy Hip Implant Lawsuits Increasing
While
many other firms have seen a drop in the number of metal hip implant clients,
Sullo and Sullo attorneys have actually seen those numbers climb. Andrew Sullo,
Class Action Lead Counsel & Managing Partner notes that “Although many firms have noticed a slowdown
in the number of clients hiring them for DePuy ASR and Pinnacle lawsuits, our
firm has not. I believe that is because we are constantly offering our clients
new and updated information. Our job is to inform all metal-on-metal hip
recipients that even though their hip may not have failed yet, it could and
after August 26th they may lose rights to recover compensation from
Johnson and Johnson.”
With
the statute of limitations coming up soon on the ASR metal-on-metal hip implant
lawsuits, Sullo & Sullo is experiencing an increase in the ASR recipients
who are coming forward and asking to be a part of the lawsuit. Many clients in
the lawsuit have experienced adverse health effects as a direct result of
having an ASR all metal hip implant put into their body. On the other hand, many have experienced
little or no pain with their ASR hip implant but have elected to join the
lawsuit that they can be financial protected at a point in the future should
their ASR device fail. Through no fault of their own, these people have become
victims of a heavily flawed system which allows harmful medical devices to be
sold to the public. The ASR was approved in 2005 by the FDA under the
controversial 510(k) process which allows medical devices to essentially ride
in on the coattails of other medical devices which have come before them. In
some cases approval is granted based on a device which has actually been
discontinued because of the number of problems associated with it.
July 27, 2012
Current Updates on the DePuy ASR Hip Recall
The
DePuy ASR metal-on-metal hip implant was approved in 2005 by the FDA, but soon
thereafter both DePuy and the FDA began receiving reports of adverse health
events. Some believe that the much less rigorous 510(k) approval process which
allows manufacturers to skip clinical trials could be at least partially
responsible for the adverse health effects in the thousands of ASR recipients.
Following a flurry of complaints, DePuy voluntarily recalled the ASR on August
26, 2010. At present there are approximately 4000 DePuy ASR lawsuits
consolidated into an MDL in Ohio as well as a smaller mini-state consolidation
in Chicago with approximately 600 plaintiffs and another in California
containing 1500 or so plaintiffs. Since California is experiencing so many
financial problems, the plaintiffs and their attorneys are expected to face
problems in getting a trial setting.
The
MDL, or multi-district litigation system is meant to streamline the litigation
process, taking advantage of the fact that there are similar allegations from
all plaintiffs made against the defendants—in this case DePuy and Johnson and
Johnson. The first trial regarding the ASR was scheduled to begin in state
court in Las Vegas in mid-December although it has been rumored the case
settled prior to trial. Should this be true, it would be a positive precedent
for all other ASR lawsuits to follow. The metal-on-metal design came about due
to its ability to last significantly longer than the metal-on-ceramic or
metal-on-plastic hip implants. Unfortunately, the metal-on-metal design allowed
the cobalt and chromium ball and cup to shave off microscopic metal ions into
the body, entering the surrounding tissues or even the bloodstream. The FDA
recently held a two-day panel to discuss the safety of the metal hip implant.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)