As
of this date the Pinnacle metal-on-metal hip implant device manufactured by
DePuy has not followed in the recall footsteps of DePuy’s other hip implant,
the ASR. While Johnson and Johnson and DePuy vigorously deny that the Pinnacle
has any problems—and, in fact, call it the best metal-on-metal hip implant on
the market today—many recipients of the device feel it has some of the same flaws
as the ASR. Both the Pinnacle and the ASR are manufactured by Johnson and
Johnson’s subsidiary company, DePuy. The Pinnacle made its debut in 2002 as the
predecessor of the ASR which followed in 2005. The ASR is strictly a
metal-on-metal hip implant device while the Pinnacle name includes
metal-on-ceramic and metal on polyethylene models as well.
Nearly
150,000 Pinnacle all-metal hip replacements have been implanted compared to
93,000 ASR’s worldwide—approximately half of those in the United States alone.
Both the Pinnacle and the ASR all-metal hip implants were approved under the
controversial 510(k) FDA approval process. This particular process allows the
majority of medical devices to get to market quickly by showing they are
substantially comparable to a device which has already gained approval. The
process also allows a product to get to market without expensive clinical
trials however in some cases the approval process has been predicated on a
device which is no longer marketed—even due to poor performance.