April 5, 2012

The ASR Acetabular System falls far short of other total hip replacement systems. Here's how.

By Independent Staff Writer


In a previous article we wrote on bone deterioration, we discussed how the bones of your hip are constructed and how a hip implant strives to mimic the qualities so that you can maintain a normal range of movement and a fairly active life.
In this article, we'd like to show you how the ASR XL Acetabular System was constructed - and why it fell so short of what hip implant patients needed to give them back their previous quality of life.

What a Hip Implant is Up Against
Any hip implant is going head-to-head against the natural construction of your body, which is no easy feat. What we think of as our hip is actually two bones: the acetabulum (also called the hip socket) and the femoral head, which is the rounded top of your femur (the main bone that runs the length of your thigh).
hip1
As you can see, the two bones of your hip are actually attached to each other securely by two ligaments. The shorter ligament at the center of the femur head is the transverse acetabular ligament, while the longer ligament that runs from the ilium down to the femur itself is the iliofemoral ligament.
These ligaments, along with the cartilage surrounding the hip joint, are the reason your hip doesn't dislocate on a regular basis. The iliofemoral ligament in particular is extraordinarily strong - in fact, the strongest ligament in the human body - and when you are standing or sitting, this ligament flexes or releases to allow a range of movement without letting the hip move out of the socket.
For its part, the transverse acetabular ligament and the surrounding cartilage make up the acetabular labrum, whose purpose is to deepen the hip socket so that the head of the femur can't slip out. The deeper the hip socket, the more secure the femur bone becomes and the less likely your hip will dislocate.
When your natural hip is removed to make way for a hip implant, neither of those ligaments is in place, and the cushion of cartilage is removed to make way for an artificial replacement. Removing the labrum means that your hip is 92% more likely to suffer contact stresses and 40% more likely to allow the femur and acetabulum to touch.
As you can see, your hip is a sophisticated and well-constructed mechanism, and it is extremely difficult to create a man-made replacement for it. Let's take a look at some of the best attempts available in the form of conventional hip replacement and total hip replacement systems, including the ASR Acetabular System. 

Women have a disproportionally larger number of problems with hip implant surgery than men do. Especially with the ASR XL Acetabular System.

By Independent Staff Writer


Several news sources, among them the New York Times, have already commented on the mounting data that more women than men are reporting problems with the ASR XL Acetabular System. We'd like to explain exactly why that is.

Problem: Hip Implant Not Designed Ideally for Wider Hip Sockets
Women, as you may have heard, are structured differently anatomically than men. The differences aren't merely on the surface, however; they extend into the skeletal structure and particularly in the pelvis region. Women have wider hips with bigger hip sockets to accommodate the process of giving birth, which means they often have more problems in hip implant surgery because those large hip sockets allow the implant to dislocate more easily.
In the DePuy ASR XL Acetabular System, however, the problems go beyond the norm. One of the reasons is that the hip implant was designed to be extremely shallow, exacerbating the problems women already have with hip implants.

Problem: Women More Likely to Require Hip Implants
Women are more prone to osteopenia, osteoporosis, and often have weaker bones overall than men, particularly as they age. The onset of menopause, and the subsequent drop in estrogen, have been linked to rapid bone deterioration. Because of all of these factors, women are more likely than men overall to require a hip implant because of a hip fracture.
Problem: Small, Shallow Hip Implant
The DePuy ASR XL Acetabular System was designed to give patients a greater range of motion. If you'll recall, the design of the hip implant included two parts: an implant inserted into the femur bone with a rounded top that fit into a cup placed in the hip bone.
In the design of the ASR XL Acetabular System, the cup was made very shallow, which meant that the patient could move their leg in a wider arc before the other part of the implant might dislocate.
Good in theory. And if DePuy had tested their product properly, it might have worked quite well. In real life, it went a little differently.
The shallow hip implants meant that all of the friction caused by everyday movement was focused on a much smaller area. There was more force on a smaller amount of material. The hip implant was under more stress and was more prone to the friction that caused small metal ions to break off into the bloodstream. It was also more likely to break altogether.
Especially in women. Their smaller, shallower hip implants meant there was even more strain on the material. Women who have an ASR XL Acetabular System are reporting problems in greater numbers than men in part because their hip implants are simply breaking down faster. They have the same problems, forced upon a smaller area.
Our consulting doctor offered some sobering statistics for smaller hip implants in general: the risk of a hip revision surgery for a hip implant with a head size of 44 mm is five times that of a hip implant with a head size of 55 mm.

Many patients who received a DePuy hip implant have suffered heavy metal poisoning. But what does that really mean?

By Independent Staff Writer


As we try to describe the reasons the DePuy ASR XL Acetabular System present such a danger to your health, we occasionally use terms you may be only vaguely familiar with. This is an ongoing series of articles on the medical terms related to the DePuy hip recall and hip revision surgeries.
Heavy metal poisoning, by its strictest definition, is simply the build-up of heavy metals in the soft tissues of the body. It is also referred to as heavy metal toxicity. The most common heavy metals associated with poisoning are lead, mercury, arsenic, and cadmium; the ones that are in the structure of the DePuy ASR XL Acetabular hip implant are chromium and cobalt.

One doctor who analyzed several patients who were tested for metal poisoning said that these were some of the highest levels for chromium and cobalt ions he has ever seen. Despite this, he also said that many of the patients had no symptoms, which makes for a very good argument that any patients who received an ASR XL Acetabular System should be monitored closely and receive regular blood tests.
For any kind of heavy metal poisoning, the symptoms largely revolve around the digestive system: nausea, vomiting, diarrhea, and stomach pain, for example. Patients may also have headaches or get a metallic taste in their mouths. In extreme cases, heavy metal poisoning may make patients lose cognitive, motor, and language function.

Could the DePuy ASR™ XL Acetabular System recall have been avoided? Looks like it.

By Independent Staff Writer

In August 2005, the FDA approved an application for the DePuy ASRTM XL Acetabular System, allowing DePuy to market the new, metal-on-metal system to patients needing total hip replacement surgery. To those patients, this FDA approval meant one thing: the DePuy ASRTM XL Acetabular System was safe.
But, in its first five years, the ASR System failed at such catastrophic rates that DePuy issued a voluntary recall in August 2010, affecting tens of thousands of patients who have to undergo revision surgery.
How could this happen? Isn't it the FDA's job to verify and ensure the safety and effectiveness of medical devices sold in the United States? 

The admitted failure rate of the ASR XL Acetabular System is 13%-meaning, this is the number acknowledged by DePuy. Mounting evidence suggests that the failure rate is higher than that, especially if one doesn't limit the definition of "failure" to DePuy's narrow view.
The DePuy ASRTM XL Acetabular System gained FDA approval through the 510(k) process, which bypasses clinical testing altogether if the product is "sufficiently equivalent" to other products already on the market. 

Which means the ASR System was never clinically tested before it was sold to patients, and it underwent only the most rudimentary safety tests. DePuy only had to state that their new product raised no new safety concerns. The FDA - evidently - took them at their word.
Congress and consumer advocacy groups have been calling for of the 510(k) process,in part due to similar recalls from DePuy and other medical device companies. As of August 2010, the FDA has issued two preliminary reports that recommend sweeping changes.
The reports indicate that consumer advocacy groups had strong concerns about "predicate quality"-that is, the quality of the already approved devices to which DePuy claimed their new product was substantially equivalent.
Per the current 510(k) requirements, a company can claim its product is substantially equivalent to a product that never underwent clinical testing, was made before 1976, or had been recalled. That's right: the ASR System got through on a kind of loophole, and now another manufacturer can come along and claim their product is substantially equivalent to it-and be approved.
Had this negligence been rectified years ago, the ASRTM XL Acetabular System might never have gone to market. 

The preliminary reports also recommend getting rid of the rule that allows a company to base its substantial equivalence claims on more than one product. This change would almost surely have invalidated DePuy's ASRTM XL Acetabular System application, because DePuy based its substantial equivalence claim on no fewer than three devices.
Perhaps most important, the reports call for an improvement in the quality of the clinical data submitted to support substantial equivalence. How has the FDA justified making an educated decision about a new product's safety and effectiveness without strong clinical data?
If DePuy had been mandated to conduct clinical studies before the ASR System was sent to market, the terrible fact of a one-in-eight revision rate might've been avoided. Tens of thousands of patients might've been spared the painful truth that will need to undergo a second hip implant just a few years after receiving the first. 

Too many ASR XL Acetabular Systems causing problems in first three years.

By Independent Staff Writer


In 2003, DePuy released the ASRTM XL Acetabular System, a hip implant that was touted to last up to 20 years with a stronger, more durable metal-on-metal design. Approximately 93,000 people around the world weighed the risks of surgery against their current level of pain and discomfort and chose to receive a hip implant that they believed would give them 15 to 20 years of pain-free movement.
DePuy issued a hip recall earlier this year, which means a disturbing number of those patients will likely have to undergo a hip revision surgery-years ahead of schedule. 

With a typical hip replacement, the patient is able to resume a normal life after three to six months of recovery. There are a number of "common" problems, such as loosening joints, fractures, and occasionally dislocation. Hip implant recipients are informed beforehand that the risk of these types of failure is .5-3%
The admitted failure rate of the ASR XL Acetabular System is 13%-meaning, this is the number acknowledged by DePuy. Mounting evidence suggests that the failure rate is higher than that, especially if one doesn't limit the definition of "failure" to DePuy's narrow view. 

The major flaw, as we've said in other articles about the problems with the XL Acetabular System, is the engineering. The two pieces of the implant rub together as the patient moves, releasing microscopic particles of chromium and cobalt into the bloodstream. Some patients experience pain when this happens; others have no idea of the damage being done to the bone and tissue surrounding the hip implant. Some patients and doctors have reported a loosening of the joints in the hip implant, fracturing of the surrounding bone, and full-out dislocation. 

Every hip implant releases small particles of the device's materials into the bloodstream, but the quantities are so small that the body can release them from the bloodstream as waste. In the ASR XL Acetabular System, the quantities being released are sometimes so great that the body can't get rid of them efficiently, causing metallosis.

Choosing a good lawyer isn't as difficult as you might imagine; it's just a matter of asking the right questions.

By Independent Staff Writer


With so many lawyers out there, how should you go about finding a good one? How can you tell a strong lawyer from a weak one? You need solid legal advice, and you want the right attorney. Do not, we repeat, DO NOT just open the phone book, close your eyes, and point to a name. Here are some guideposts to help you. 

A good lawyer is ethical.
You're probably laughing right now. Can the words "ethics" and "lawyer" exist in the same sentence? Actually, it is possible, and you should absolutely insist on it. But how can you tell if a lawyer is ethical? There are some pretty good indicators.
What types of cases does he take?
Lawyers have a choice about which cases they take. Look at her winning cases as well as the losing ones. No lawyer wants to lose a case, but an ethical lawyer will often be willing to take a case because it is the right thing to do and fight to the very end.
Look at whether the lawyer actually tries the cases he takes in court or whether he just gathers cases for others. Ask the attorney when he last went to trial. Ask him how often his cases settle and how often his cases make it to a jury.
Be sure that the lawyer specializes in your type of case. You really don't want a tax attorney to represent you in your personal injury case. An ethical attorney will only take cases in her area of expertise.
What types of clients does he represent?
Does he represent big corporations or everyday people? Does he fight for the underdog? Does he hold wrongdoers accountable for their behavior?
Is he honest?

How the ASR XL Acetabular System Causes Bone Deterioration...And what it means for your future hip revision surgeries.

By Taylor Lindstrom

When DePuy issued their hip recall, they offered to pay for the revision surgery needed to replace the faulty hip with a new implant. They appear to believe this is the full extent of their responsibility in repairing the damage they've done to thousands of people who had a hip replacement implanted in their bodies.
It's not enough. Because the damage the ASR XL Acetabular system caused doesn't end when the hip is removed. It's only just beginning. 

How Your Hips Work
If this were an after-school special, we'd show you a few clips at this point: Elvis shaking his hips on stage back in the day, or a ballet dancer extending her leg over her head. The after-school special would be missing the point, however - your hips are essential to nearly every movement you make. You use them every time you stand, sit, crouch, or lean over. You use them getting into and out of cars, climbing up the porch steps to your front door, even just standing there. 

A hip is a little bit like oxygen. You don't notice how essential it is until it's gone.
There's a reason you barely notice your hip's contribution to your everyday movements: your body has constructed it more or less perfectly. The hip bone is a portion of your pelvis, and it has a rounded cup-shape in its center into which the top of your femur bone fits, called the acetabulum.
The top of your femur fits smoothly into the acetabulum and rotates when you move, cushioned by synovial fluid that naturally lubricates the hip joint. When you get a hip implant, the idea is to mimic this natural construction of your hip joint as closely as possible, including the range of rotation, the lubrication, and the way the ball (the head) and socket (the acetabulum) fit together.
How a Hip Implant Works
There are two basic ways of affixing the hip implant to the rest of your skeleton. In both, the top of your femur is sawn off and replaced with an artificial new head, while the hip bone itself is shaved down to accommodate a man-made socket. Essentially, the acetabulum is carved out to the shape of the new socket.
The difference lies in how the new femur head and socket are attached to the surrounding bone. In older patients, the most common tactic is to use a bone cement to attach them. In younger patients, however, the surrounding bone is still versatile and capable of regrowth. Since cement has some serious drawbacks, including the risk that it will shrink or crack over time and the fact that it is not especially secure when it comes to withstanding forceful movements like jumping, another procedure has been developed for younger patients.